There has finally been more talk over the past year or so about how eating meat contributes to our environmental ills. Mark Bittman devoted much his latest book, Food Matters, to reasons why going vegan helps the environment, and the energy cost of raising meat, the colossal amounts of environmental crud produced by factory farms, and the hideous treatment of the animals (and workers) have been well-documented.
Curiously, though, you never see folks like Bittman and Michael Pollan talking about not wearing leather, or buying leather furniture, or avoiding a car with leather seats. These things, though, can be even worse for the environment. Much leather is produced shipped from overseas, particularly from India and Mexico, where tanneries may be subject to far fewer environmental regulations. They spew millions of liters of toxins every day, including hexavalent chromium, the kidney-killing stuff Erin Brockovich went to bat against.
Worse, tannieries often use child labor, particularly those in India, which has the largest number of laborers under the age of 14 in the world. Check out this piece from the Times of India:
Next time you visit the Park Circus area, after adjusting your olfactory organ to the stench tanneries are associated with, if you take a peek behind the high brick walls of a tannery, chances are that you might catch a glimpse of a group of children. Ranging from six to 16, they are working hard from dawn to dusk making shoes. Take, for example, Mintu Mondal (12), Sonu Khan (8) and Salim Akhtar (9). They work daily in one such tanneries for nine hours a day for a meagre Rs 10 daily wage. Sonu, the youngest, has developed white patches all over his hands. “It itches, but what to do? I’ll have to earn money,” he said.
The children who are engaged in these tanneries rinse, sink, conserve and dye hides with chemicals, apart from drying, pigmenting and measuring finished hides. Dr Jayanta Das, a city dermatologist, said, “These children are most susceptible to skin diseases like dermatitis, fungal infection etc because of over-exposure to corrosive chemicals. Bacterial contamination from the raw skin may lead to deadly diseases like anthracosis and tuberculosis. Even research reveals, these children develop a serious psychic problem.”
The whole leather topic seems to be a sticky wicket, because my vegetarian friends, even those who are committed to animal rights (most are unaware of the child labor issue), seem unable to completely do away with leather.
One says, "You gotta draw the line somewhere." (Yo, L., that's a dead cow on your back!) Another, tries her best to avoid leather but, like me, sometimes ends up buying leather shoes, and bags with the occasional leather trim. When she talks about why she's a vegetarian, she says she never mentions humane or environmental issues, being acutely aware of the hypocrisy.
As far as I know, there are no products out there trumpeting sustainably or humanely raised and processed leather. (Correct me if I'm wrong, please.) The alternative, then, is to avoid leather, just like I avoid factory-farmed meat. And the more I look, the more possibilities I'm finding. In fact, I think it's easier to stop buying leather than to find humanely raised meat. Low-hanging fruit. I'm going for it, and I'll document each time I successfully avoid leather.
In my next installement on this topic, I'll do a roundup of the groovy vegan accessories available.
~BurbMom
Photo: A tannery spills effluent into the water near Kasur, a border town in Pakistan. Kamila Hyat/IRIN
Recent Comments